A winter wonderland and our Christmas dilemma….
Peaking out the window this morning I wasn’t surprised or disappointed to see that, not only was the snow still with us, but there was even MORE of it. A great big dollop had been delivered through the night.
Deciding to leave the car at home I figured the walk to work would be stress free and I could enjoy the snow – it is so beautiful here today because not only do we have lots of the white powdery stuff, but the sun is shining, making my wee Scottish world look quite magical.
Dawning my lovely fake fur coat (a recent lovely purchase from the charity shop) my warm wooly hat that comes right down over my lugs and my trusty hiking boots I headed off.
Now there is something about walking in the snow that makes people chat. Adverse weather seems to break down all sorts of barriers and perhaps giving people a common goal – to make it to their destination.
It wasn’t long before I was joined on my trek by an elderly stranger called Emma, a semi retired lady going in my direction (for a while at least). Only a few paces in and Emma had filled me in on how she fills her days of retirement and also how she copes with memory loss. We had a lovely, if rather disjointed conversation, peppered with Emma saying, ‘what was I saying?’. Emma may have been struggling to keep up with the conversation but I was struggling to keep up with Emma, who demands a surprising staggering walking pace from anyone that cares to join her. Our walk together ended at the park with Emma headed off down one lane, while I took the other. Shouting goodbyes she happily trekked off into the beautiful wilderness.
Trudging along my mind turned to Christmas and in particular the debate in our house about this year’s Christmas tree. Having always been a ‘real tree’ house we are considering an artificial tree this year. Now before any of you traditionalist start shouting at your computer screens hear me out. In all honesty I’m with you, I love a real tree and the hassle that go with it doesn’t register in my life. I love the smell, the chaos of putting it up (and getting it out of the house after the festivities without depositing ALL of the needles throughout the house – which interesting never happens).
My husband Peter is usually charged with getting the tree. Each year, despite discussions about what size of tree we are going with, he faithfully returns with the BIGGEST tree he can find. Last year he achieved a personal best – it must have been an eight or nine footer at least.
Real trees are getting more and more expensive and we could buy a pretty good artificial tree that would last years – rather than shelling out every year for a real one. Ok, I know, there is also the environmental debate. From what I’ve read natural tree growers argue that artificial trees are more environmentally harmful than real trees (well they would, wouldn’t they). On the other side of the argument allegedly artificial trees have excellent recyclable properties. However I think I’m with the researcher from Kansas State University who called the idea that artificial trees are eco-friendly as an ‘urban myth’.
So what to do, buy an artificial tree and use it FOREVER MORE, never to dispose of it in landfill and benefit from the financial saving each year, or go for a real life traditional Christmas tree?
I will happily sit on the fence on this one. I’ll just be delighted to have ‘A’ tree and get this Christmas thing going in our house. So husband ‘Buyer of the Tree’ I’ll leave it with you – but if you go down the route of a real tree how about this one – it tops your record last year, and then some!
So guys what do you think – real or artificial?

















Yes I agree about walking in the snow. I did just that yesterday on my way to the bus station. Only problem was that my case on wheels acted like a snow plough, but it did bring smiles from folk who all wanted to chat. A lovley start to my day, especially as there is not a sighn of any here in Pembrokeshire.
So to the tree question. The smell of a fresh one is something secial. There are some excellent artificial ones around just now.
Thank you Aileen. I’m glad you made it home safely. As for the tree, yes, I agree, the smell of a real tree can’t be beaten.
Real every time – the smell of a real tree cannot be beaten. And I think we should ban artificial ones – real ones biodegrade without the need for any processing/incineration etc. Most tree growers work from sustainable forests – for every tree cut they plant 2 or three. Not to mention ‘taste’ … I mean have you seen some of the artificial trees – TREES ARE NOT WHITE – OR PURPLE!
No go for real every time I say!
I am not envious of your snow but it is pretty !
Thank you PhD. I hadn’t really looked much into the environmental issues around real v artificial and was quite surprised at what I found. Even worse than the white or purple are the fibre optic ones – oh no actually I can top that, there are trees that come fully decorated that you just stick into a stand. Surely decorating it is the best bit?
Real every time! Though I haven’t had one at all for the last 3 years!
I’m looking at out a cold rain. I wish it was snowing. Of course, I don’t have to go anywhere and I live in a condo development where someone else does the plowing ans shoveling…
I say if you must, decorate a live tree outside. Mother nature needs her trees…
Interesting idea!
I’m going with real too – there’s nothing quite like a real Christmas tree and all the excitement of choosing it, preparing it, putting it up and looking after it. Can’t beat it, in my opinion. This year, we don’t have much money, so opted for a budget one which, although quite shortish, does the job quite nicely.
Have fun deciding
Sue xx
ps Love the snowy photos Jacqueline.
I know what you mean Sue. When I lived in the cottage I could only have a small tree – but it was always beautiful. Big isn’t everything.
Real! Not only do they smell and look gorgeous but the following winter the dry branches make the best kindling for a log fire.
Ha ha, I just have to say, when I saw your top picture, I thought it was a seriously impressive picture of a mountain with two snowy peaks, and a beautiful snowy sky. Then I saw the caption and spent ages trying to work out how that could be. Now that I see, I can’t believe I saw something so different, as once pointed out, it’s very obvious! D’oh! In my defence, I was looking at it from a distance…. Ahem.
I just went back and looked at this photograph Rosie, I see what you mean.
I’m a real tree person. In fact, I discovered plastic trees in the UK, and just find them awful (sorry): they look like any plastic plant, fake and kitsch, and they just don’t smell!!
I’m a real tree person too if I’m honest – even if it’s a small an inexpensive one then I would be happy. Either that and I might have to go all arty and create something – got lots of ideas. We’ll see how things pan out – will let you know.